First, watch this classic, short clip from “Sunset Boulevard,” with Wm. Holden and Gloria Swanson
Studio Blues (the session)
So we’re sittin around
mid-session/post-mortem
We are, so far, not happy
It doesn’t sound like us at all
The urge to get it right
to project confidence and
unity in the band’s sound…
Technology can get in the way:
Today was a clusterfrack of
padded drums with five mikes
and 64 tracks on the sound board
and an OCD tech whose mantra is
“Perrrrrrr-fect”
(If he were a makeup artist,
a single smudge would be verboten)
Inquisitive as to our dissatisfaction
(this being an old-style jazz recording)
he joins us and digs into the
delicious coffee cake make by
the bass player’s girlfriend. I activate
the discussion: “It’s too clean.”
Tech gets defensive. “I’ve made
stellar recordings for (so-and-so)
It takes the master’s touch to clean up
the blips and merge all the tracks.”
“Look,” sez I, “let’s do a Sinatra session.
Strip the drums – Mike, use brushes
Jimmy, get your stand-up bass, no more electric
Screw the keyboard effects, Stu, just
tickle the baby grand in the corner. One
mike on that, and I’ll sing in the center,
Billie-style. Lower the lights and let’s
get the mood right.” Tech is instructed
to merge all tracks simultaneously and
create a single, live session. “But there
will be off notes and sometimes the
guitarist squeaks on the strings!” frets he.
“You need reverb, some sweetening…”
I honey/hotsauce him: “Listen, babe,
I’m a singer, not a vocal machine, and
we want soul, not squeaky-clean.
“Wanna know how we did it when
I started out? Watch this and
get schooled, learn from someone
who came up in smoky clubs.
“Dusty Springfield sang sitting on a toilet
because the sound was better in the bathroom.
We didn’t NEED reverb then…
We had voices.”
© 2013 Amy Barlow Liberatore/Sharp Little Pencil
Well, the Real Toads had a “come one, come all” today, so I thought I’d pick up a prompt from The Sunday Whirl. This comes from my “old school” background in music, where the singers whose catalogs I raided (Sinatra, Billie, Bennett, Satch, Nat “King” Cole, the early years of Barbra Streisand) all had one thing in common: They recorded live with their band or orchestras. No fiddling around with the sound post-session.
Once Madonna came on the scene, she was sued for using a second singer’s voice to give her own so-so voice that high-nasal feel (She lip-synched most of “Like A Virgin” at the Grammy Awards, but no one noticed because she was writhing on the floor). Studios full of baffles, drum rooms, and solo vocals recorded separately after the band, a jillion tracks they could add later, as well as reverb (the first vocal enhancement) and eventually the vocanizer, which not only “sweetens” a vocal flat note but was used by Cher on “Believe (In Life After Lov e)” – that “it takes ti-i-i-ime” computerized effect, used to create an interesting vibe.
MY PEOPLE SANG. Sinatra always had an audience (women had to remove all clinky jewelry); Billie sat in the middle of a circle, mike suspended from the ceiling; Streisand, accompanied by full orchestras in her 20s, had a knack for getting her emotional performances on the very first take. Nat live in sessions, playing his own piano? The livin’ end.
In other words, things change, but I don’t have to follow the trend. None of the recordings you have heard from me have ever had any monkey business, no sweetening, etc. Pure, simple jazz. Peace, Amy
Polly Robinson
Keep doing it your way Amy, it makes you happy, so it’s best x
The Real Cie
I have very eclectic tastes in music. We often feature hard rock and metal on the Undead in the Netherworld blog, but I also enjoy jazz, blues, and a variety of other stuff. This is a cool find.
SaraV
My son just “schooled” me the other day on autotune, a device that all major singers today abuse, I mean “use”. I’m with you, if you have a great voice, that’s all you need 🙂
oldegg
It is all about being real or artificial…sort of like being dumbed down so your real personality is hidden. I can remember being carried away at trad jazz sessions at a little club in the 1950’s and being a little disappointed in buying their records where the feeling was gone. May have been the beer I was drinking!
Roger Green
Bathrooms ARE great places to sing!
whimsygizmo
Amy, this is AWESOME. I am there, for the whole session. I adore the “frets” thrown in there as verb, just for fun. Clever girl. 😉 You rock. Literally.
AR Neal
Reblogged this on One Starving Activist and commented:
As a lover of music and a former radio person, this hit home…
ihatepoetry
One of my favorite Norma Desmond moments. There’s something to be said for the digital technology, but the real proof of the artist usually stands out more au naturale! I like the honey/hotsauce him reference.
claudia
ha yes we had voices..it’s awesome what you can do with tech nowadays but i agree that the soul gets a bit lost..often it’s the imperfections that make music charming and relatable..
Steve King
You remind me of why I so enjoy live recordings. There’s nothing quite like perceiving artists being caught in the act of revealing themselves. Nice job of evoking this.
aprille
Amy, this is fascinating.
So well done. I wanted more of everything,
julespaige
Don’t change. There is just too much of that going on. I don’t question how I use a shoe horn sometimes to make the words fit. But I do all by my itty bitty self. OK maybe with the help of my muse…sometimes all you need is that inner voice to tell you what is right.
Thanks for your visit.
julespaige
Oh I did get a work out with prompt:
http://julesgemsandstuff.blogspot.com/2013/04/miz-q-8-successful-revolt.html
brian miller
i feel you in not wanting that squeeky clean as it can def wash away the soul…and sometimes you just have to strip it back down to find it again…another reason i like the pops of old vinyl…and old recordings of the garage band…the grit adds to it…
kimnelsonwrites
I love it when you write about music because you teach so much. I could read/listen to your poems and then explanations all day. This was a real treat, Amy.
Mary
Amy, I love all the behind the scenes information you give here. As Kim said, it was a real treat.
lovemorestudio
Great poem– I also really enjoyed the explanation at the end. Nice work! ~peace, Jason
Todd Alan Kraft
Having done my fair share of 4 track and GarageBand, I can totally appreciate this… I’ve spent hours tweaking knobs only to end up doing it “straight up” with very dry bass, drum kit, guitar and vocals.
Renee Espriu
Absolutely! I say you will sound ‘sweeet’ and know it’s from your soul. Love this one Amy.
I HAVE A VOICE
super captivating and a fabulous film! Terrific writing !
Rowan Taw
To capture real emotion sometimes things need to be raw – really appreciate the message here.
Wyeth Bailey
When a singer has a voice, the vibration of the vocal cords does something primal as the soy swabs reach us. It’s true and real. Your “writhing on the floor” line reminded me of when I saw Lady Gaga live last year. Midway through the lights went down, and she stretched out on her belly with a mic, and sang. First she made it clear that this was her voice, no help, no theatrics. And she sang out clear to a huge amphitheater. And it was so moving. The woman can sing, acapella, or with just a piano. But it takes theatrics to get a record contract.
othermary
This is so good, for so many reasons!
GILLENA COX
luv the conversational mood of your poem; reading it silently i felt like i was listening to your voice
much love…
margaretbednar
Tech gets defensive. “I’ve made
stellar recordings for (so-and-so)
It takes the master’s touch to clean up
the blips and merge all the tracks.”
Oh, how they like to make themselves into a god 🙂
And no need for me to watch “Sunset Blvd”… I have it memorized.
And you used a word list for this? It certainly doesn’t read that way!